Incubation

By /

“Incubation” in a business context refers to a supportive environment or program designed to help new or early-stage businesses (startups) grow and become successful. The core idea is to nurture these fledgling companies, much like an incubator nurtures a premature baby, providing them with the resources, guidance, and network they need to survive and thrive during their vulnerable initial phases.

Incubation programs are typically run by:

  • Universities: Leveraging academic research, faculty expertise, and student talent.
  • Government agencies: Promoting innovation, economic development, and job creation.
  • Corporations: Seeking innovative ideas, potential acquisitions, or strategic partnerships.
  • Venture Capital (VC) firms or private entities: As a pipeline for investment opportunities.
  • Dedicated Incubator organizations: Whose sole purpose is incubation.

Key Components and Services Offered in an Incubation Program:

While offerings vary, common components of an incubation program include:

  1. Workspace:
    • Physical Space: Affordable office space, co-working facilities, meeting rooms, and sometimes specialized labs or workshops. This reduces initial overhead for startups.
    • Virtual Incubation: Especially post-COVID, many incubators offer virtual programs without a physical space requirement, leveraging online tools for communication and mentorship.
  2. Mentorship and Guidance:
    • Experienced Mentors: Access to seasoned entrepreneurs, industry experts, and business leaders who provide advice on strategy, product development, marketing, sales, finance, and legal matters.
    • Structured Workshops: Training sessions on various aspects of running a business, from fundraising to intellectual property.
  3. Networking Opportunities:
    • Peer-to-Peer: Connecting with other startups in the incubator for collaboration, shared learning, and emotional support.
    • Investor Access: Introductions to angel investors, venture capitalists, and other funding sources.
    • Industry Connections: Facilitating introductions to potential customers, partners, and suppliers.
    • University/Corporate Resources: Access to university faculty, labs, corporate R&D departments, or industry events.
  4. Business Support Services:
    • Administrative Support: Shared administrative staff, reception services.
    • Legal & Financial Advice: Access to legal counsel for company registration, IP protection, contracts, and financial advisors for accounting, taxation, and fundraising strategy.
    • Marketing & PR Support: Assistance with branding, digital marketing, and media relations.
  5. Funding Assistance:
    • Seed Funding/Grants: Some incubators offer small amounts of initial funding or grants directly.
    • Pitch Preparation: Helping startups refine their pitches for investors.
    • Investor Introductions: Facilitating meetings with potential investors.
  6. Technology Infrastructure (sometimes):
    • High-speed internet, IT support, access to specialized software licenses, or lab equipment.

The Incubation Process (Typical Stages):

  1. Application & Selection: Startups apply to the incubator, often through a competitive process involving pitch decks, business plans, and interviews.
  2. Onboarding: Accepted startups move into the incubator’s facilities or join the virtual program.
  3. Program Duration: Incubation programs typically last for a defined period, ranging from a few months to 2-3 years, depending on the program’s intensity and the startup’s needs.
  4. Mentorship & Development: The core period of active guidance, workshops, and milestone tracking.
  5. Graduation/Exit: Startups “graduate” from the incubator once they have achieved certain milestones (e.g., secured significant funding, developed a viable product, achieved consistent revenue) and are ready to operate independently.

Incubation vs. Acceleration:

While often used interchangeably, there’s a subtle difference:

  • Incubators: Tend to focus on very early-stage startups (sometimes just an idea or a nascent prototype). They provide long-term, nurturing support, helping validate business models and build foundational elements.
  • Accelerators: Typically target slightly more mature startups that have a working prototype or some initial traction. They offer intensive, short-term (e.g., 3-6 months) programs focused on rapid growth, scaling, and investor readiness, often culminating in a “Demo Day.”

Importance of Incubation, especially in India:

In India, incubation plays a crucial role in fostering the startup ecosystem due to:

  • Entrepreneurial Boom: A large pool of young, aspiring entrepreneurs.
  • Resource Scarcity: Many first-time entrepreneurs lack access to capital, mentorship, and professional networks.
  • Government Push: Initiatives like Startup India actively promote and fund incubators to boost innovation and job creation.
  • Talent Pool: Leveraging academic talent from universities for new ventures.
  • Solving Local Problems: Nurturing startups that address unique challenges within India’s diverse markets.

Examples of prominent incubators/accelerators in India include NASSCOM CoE, T-Hub (Telangana), CIIE.CO (IIM Ahmedabad), SINE (IIT Bombay), and various university-affiliated incubators.

In essence, incubation provides a critical safety net and launchpad for startups, significantly increasing their chances of success by mitigating common early-stage risks and accelerating their development.

What is Incubation?

In a business context, incubation refers to a supportive program or environment designed to help new or early-stage businesses, often called startups, develop and grow. It provides them with the essential resources, guidance, and network they need to navigate the challenging initial phases of their existence.

Think of it like an actual incubator for a baby: it provides a controlled, protective environment with optimal conditions for growth that wouldn’t be available otherwise. For a startup, this means:

  • Nurturing: Providing a safe space to test ideas, make mistakes, and learn without the immediate pressures of the open market.
  • Support: Offering critical services that startups often can’t afford or access easily on their own.
  • Acceleration (indirectly): Helping them develop faster and more effectively than they would in isolation.

Key Components and Services Typically Offered by an Incubation Program:

  1. Shared Workspace and Infrastructure:
    • Affordable or free office space, co-working desks, meeting rooms.
    • Access to high-speed internet, printing facilities, and sometimes specialized labs or equipment.
    • This significantly reduces a startup’s initial overhead costs.
  2. Mentorship and Guidance:
    • Access to experienced entrepreneurs, industry veterans, business leaders, and subject matter experts.
    • Mentors provide advice on business strategy, product development, market fit, fundraising, legal aspects, marketing, and operations.
    • Often involves structured mentorship sessions and workshops.
  3. Networking Opportunities:
    • Peer-to-peer: Connecting with other startups in the same program, fostering collaboration, idea exchange, and shared learning.
    • Investor connections: Introductions to angel investors, venture capitalists, and other funding sources, along with pitch preparation assistance.
    • Industry connections: Facilitating introductions to potential customers, partners, and suppliers.
  4. Business Support Services:
    • Access to legal counsel (for company registration, intellectual property protection, contracts).
    • Financial advice (accounting, taxation, fundraising strategy).
    • Marketing and Public Relations support (branding, digital presence, media outreach).
    • Administrative support (reception services, mail handling).
  5. Access to Funding (sometimes directly, often indirectly):
    • Some incubators offer small seed grants or pre-seed funding.
    • More commonly, they prepare startups for external investment and connect them directly with investors.
  6. Learning and Development:
    • Workshops, seminars, and training programs on various aspects of entrepreneurship, business management, and specific industry skills.

Who runs Incubation Programs?

  • Universities: To commercialize research, foster student entrepreneurship, and create job opportunities.
  • Government Bodies: As part of national innovation policies and economic development strategies (e.g., Startup India initiatives).
  • Corporations: To scout for new technologies, business models, or potential acquisition targets.
  • Venture Capital Firms: To build a pipeline of investable companies.
  • Dedicated Private Organizations: Companies whose core business is running incubation programs.

The Incubation Process:

  1. Application & Selection: Startups apply, often through a competitive process.
  2. Program Entry: Selected startups join the program, either physically or virtually.
  3. Support Period: The duration can vary, typically from 6 months to 3 years, depending on the program and the startup’s needs.
  4. Graduation/Exit: Startups graduate once they have achieved certain milestones, such as securing significant funding, developing a sustainable business model, or reaching a certain revenue threshold.

In essence, incubation is a critical ecosystem enabler that provides early-stage startups with a protected, resource-rich environment to validate their ideas, build their foundational operations, and increase their chances of long-term success.

Who is Required Incubation?

Courtesy: The Agri business Studies

Okay, let’s frame “Who is required incubation?” not as a legal mandate (since it almost never is), but as who fundamentally needs incubation the most to survive and thrive.

Incubation is primarily “required” by early-stage startups and aspiring entrepreneurs, especially those facing significant resource constraints, knowledge gaps, or a need for rapid validation and growth.

Here’s a breakdown of the types of entities and individuals who are essentially “required” to seek incubation for their best chance of success:

1. Early-Stage Startups (especially Pre-Seed and Seed Stage):

These are the primary beneficiaries and often the most in need of incubation.

  • Idea-Stage Ventures: Companies with just a concept, hypothesis, or a very early prototype. They need help validating their market, refining their value proposition, and building their minimum viable product (MVP).
  • First-Time Entrepreneurs: Individuals who may have great technical skills or innovative ideas but lack experience in business fundamentals (finance, marketing, sales, legal, team building).
  • Bootstrapped Startups with Limited Capital: Those operating on very tight budgets benefit immensely from free or subsidized office space, shared resources, and access to a network that can lead to initial funding.
  • Startups in Niche or Deep-Tech Sectors: Companies working on cutting-edge technologies (e.g., AI, biotech, advanced materials) often require specialized lab facilities, expensive equipment, and highly specific mentorship that only incubators can provide.
  • Social Enterprises: Startups with a dual mission of profit and social impact often benefit from incubators focused on social innovation, which can connect them with relevant grants and impact investors.

2. Aspiring Entrepreneurs and Innovators:

Individuals or small teams who are thinking about starting a business but haven’t fully committed or developed a clear plan.

  • Students/Researchers with Commercializable Ideas: University incubators are perfect for academics who have groundbreaking research but need help translating it into a viable business.
  • Professionals Transitioning to Entrepreneurship: Individuals leaving corporate jobs who need to learn the ropes of running a startup.
  • Teams without a Clear Business Model: Those who have a product or technology but are still figuring out their target market, revenue streams, and go-to-market strategy.

3. Startups Needing Specific Domain Expertise or Network:

Some startups might be generally well-off but need a very particular type of support.

  • Access to Industry Experts: If a startup is in a highly specialized field (e.g., MedTech, AgriTech), an incubator with strong ties to that industry can provide invaluable mentorship and connections.
  • Government/Academic Connections: For startups needing to navigate government regulations or access university research facilities, incubators associated with these bodies are essential.
  • Investor Readiness: Startups ready to raise their first significant round of funding benefit from incubators that specialize in pitch preparation, investor introductions, and deal structuring.

4. Startups Aiming for Rapid Validation and Market Entry:

While accelerators are more focused on rapid scaling, incubators provide the initial rapid validation needed before scaling.

  • MVP Development: Getting guidance on what features are truly essential for an MVP and how to launch it quickly.
  • Early Customer Feedback: Leveraging the incubator’s network to connect with potential early adopters and gather crucial feedback.

Why is it a “Requirement” for Them?

For these specific groups, incubation is often a near-requirement because it significantly mitigates the most common reasons for startup failure:

  • Lack of Funding: Incubators provide direct grants or crucial investor access.
  • Lack of Mentorship/Experience: They fill knowledge gaps and provide guidance.
  • Isolation: They offer a community and network for collaboration and support.
  • High Initial Costs: They provide subsidized resources.
  • Market Misalignment: They help validate ideas before significant investment.

Without incubation, many of these startups would struggle immensely, burn through capital quickly, make critical early mistakes, or simply fail to launch. Therefore, for these specific early-stage needs, incubation is not a luxury, but a strategic necessity for survival and growth.

When is required incubation?

“When is incubation required?” points to specific junctures in a startup’s journey or market conditions where the supportive environment of an incubator becomes essential for survival, validation, or accelerated development.

Here are the key “when” scenarios that necessitate incubation:

1. When a Startup is at the Idea or Very Early Stage (Pre-Seed/Seed):

  • Scenario: An entrepreneur or team has a novel idea, a nascent technology, or a rough prototype but lacks a fully validated business model, market understanding, or initial traction. They might be operating with limited funds (bootstrapped).
  • Why incubation is required: This is the most vulnerable phase. Incubators provide the crucial environment to:
    • Validate the idea: Test assumptions, conduct market research, and ensure there’s a genuine problem-solution fit.
    • Develop an MVP (Minimum Viable Product): Get guidance on building the essential features needed for early testing.
    • Refine the business model: Figure out revenue streams, pricing, and go-to-market strategies.
    • Build the initial team: Access to networks for co-founders or early employees.
    • Conserve capital: Benefit from subsidized workspace and shared resources, making limited initial funds last longer.
  • Timing: Immediately after the initial idea generation, or when a small team is formed but before significant external funding has been secured.

2. When First-Time Entrepreneurs Lack Business Experience:

  • Scenario: Individuals with strong technical skills, domain expertise, or innovative ideas but limited practical experience in sales, marketing, finance, legal, or team management.
  • Why incubation is required: Incubators bridge this knowledge gap by providing:
    • Mentorship: Access to seasoned entrepreneurs and industry experts who guide them through the pitfalls of starting a business.
    • Structured Learning: Workshops and training sessions on critical business functions they might not be familiar with.
    • Professional Services: Connections to legal and financial advisors for foundational aspects like company registration, IP protection, and accounting.
  • Timing: From the very inception of their entrepreneurial journey, or as soon as they realize their skill set is strong in one area but weak in others.

3. When Specialized Resources or Infrastructure are Needed:

  • Scenario: Startups working in deep technology (e.g., biotech, advanced manufacturing, robotics, AI hardware) that require specific lab facilities, expensive equipment, or high-performance computing.
  • Why incubation is required: Many startups cannot afford or independently set up such specialized infrastructure. Incubators (especially university or corporate-affiliated ones) often provide:
    • Access to labs: Wet labs, fabrication labs, clean rooms, etc.
    • Shared equipment: Reducing capital expenditure for early-stage companies.
    • Technical expertise: Mentors or faculty with specific scientific or engineering knowledge.
  • Timing: As soon as the startup moves beyond theoretical concepts and requires hands-on development and testing that necessitates specialized facilities.

4. When Access to Networks and Funding is Crucial for Next Steps:

  • Scenario: A startup has validated its idea and perhaps has an MVP, but needs to connect with angel investors, venture capitalists, or industry partners to scale.
  • Why incubation is required: Incubators act as crucial connectors:
    • Investor Introductions: Direct pathways to relevant funding sources.
    • Pitch Preparation: Guidance on crafting compelling pitches for investors.
    • Industry Partnerships: Facilitating introductions to potential customers, distributors, or strategic collaborators.
    • Peer Network: Learning from and collaborating with other startups facing similar challenges.
  • Timing: As the startup approaches its pre-seed or seed funding round, or when it needs to forge key partnerships to enter the market.

5. When Government Support or Specific Ecosystem Connections are Desired:

  • Scenario: Startups looking to benefit from government schemes, university research, or specific industry clusters.
  • Why incubation is required: Government-backed or university-affiliated incubators provide:
    • Grants and Funding: Access to specific government grants or university research funds (e.g., under Startup India initiatives).
    • Academic Expertise: Collaboration with university faculty and access to research findings.
    • Policy Understanding: Guidance on navigating regulatory frameworks specific to their industry.
  • Timing: From the outset, if the startup’s core idea is linked to academic research, public welfare, or a sector with significant government incentives.

In essence, incubation is “required” at the fragile beginnings of a startup’s life, and whenever critical resources, mentorship, or network connections are missing that would otherwise prevent the startup from progressing, validating its ideas, or securing initial funding. It’s about filling fundamental gaps that, left unaddressed, often lead to early-stage failure.

Where is Required Incubation?

When discussing “where is incubation required?”, we’re not talking about a specific geographical location like a city or country. Instead, we’re referring to the types of environments, ecosystems, and organizational contexts where the presence of incubation programs is either highly necessary or critically beneficial for fostering innovation and new ventures.

Here’s where incubation is “required”:

1. In Thriving Startup Ecosystems:

  • Why it’s required: Even in vibrant startup hubs, early-stage companies need dedicated support to navigate the initial complexities and competition. Incubators act as filtration systems, nurturing the most promising ideas and connecting them to the wider ecosystem.
  • Examples of locations (and their associated incubators):
    • Bengaluru, India: Known as India’s “Silicon Valley,” it has numerous incubators like NASSCOM CoE, Target Accelerator, and various university incubators (e.g., IISc, IIT-B’s SINE presence).
    • Mumbai/Pune, India: Growing startup hubs with incubators like Venture Centre (NCL Pune), SINE (IIT Bombay), and various corporate accelerators.
    • National Capital Region (NCR), India: Home to many startups and incubators like Startup Tunnel, AIC T-Hub Foundation (Hyderabad), etc.
    • Global Hubs: Silicon Valley (USA), London (UK), Tel Aviv (Israel), Berlin (Germany), all thrive with a dense network of incubators and accelerators.

2. Within Educational Institutions (Universities & Research Centers):

  • Why it’s required: To bridge the gap between academic research and commercialization. Universities are hotbeds of innovation, but researchers often lack entrepreneurial skills or market understanding. University incubators help translate lab ideas into viable businesses.
  • Examples:
    • IIT Bombay’s SINE (Society for Innovation & Entrepreneurship): One of India’s oldest and most successful incubators, fostering deep-tech and science-based startups emerging from IIT research.
    • CIIE.CO (Centre for Innovation, Incubation and Entrepreneurship) at IIM Ahmedabad: Focuses on ventures with societal impact and scalable business models.
    • Various State Universities: Many universities across India are setting up incubators as part of government pushes for innovation (e.g., under Startup India, Atal Innovation Mission).
    • IISc Bangalore, IIT Delhi, IIT Madras: All have strong incubation centers.

3. As Part of Government-Led Innovation Initiatives:

  • Why it’s required: Governments use incubation as a key tool for economic development, job creation, and fostering innovation in specific sectors. They often fund or establish incubators to achieve policy goals.
  • Examples:
    • Startup India Initiative (Government of India): Actively promotes and supports a network of incubators and accelerators across the country.
    • Atal Innovation Mission (AIM): Through Atal Incubation Centres (AICs) and Atal Community Innovation Centres (ACICs), AIM aims to create and promote a culture of innovation and entrepreneurship.
    • State-Level Policies: Many Indian states (e.g., Telangana’s T-Hub, Kerala Startup Mission) have their own robust incubation policies and dedicated facilities.

4. Within Large Corporations (Corporate Incubators/Accelerators):

  • Why it’s required: Corporations use incubation to foster internal innovation, scout for new technologies or business models, access external talent, and identify potential acquisition targets or strategic partners.
  • Examples:
    • Various IT giants, automotive companies, and financial institutions in India run their own incubation or acceleration programs (often focused on specific technologies like AI, IoT, FinTech) to drive open innovation.
    • Target Accelerator (Target India): Focuses on retail technology startups.
    • Barclays Rise (Mumbai): A FinTech innovation hub.

5. In Regions or Sectors with Emerging Potential:

  • Why it’s required: To stimulate economic growth and innovation in regions that may not have a well-developed startup ecosystem yet, or in nascent industry sectors.
  • Examples:
    • Tier 2/3 Cities in India: Initiatives to establish incubators in cities like Nagpur, Indore, Vizag, and Jaipur to decentralize startup growth and tap into local talent.
    • Specific Sector Hubs: An AgriTech incubator in a prominent agricultural region, or a CleanTech incubator near renewable energy projects.

6. Where Specialized Support or Infrastructure is Needed:

  • Why it’s required: Some startups require specific, often expensive, infrastructure or highly niche expertise that a general co-working space cannot provide.
  • Examples:
    • Biotech/MedTech Incubators: Requiring wet labs, sterile environments, or specialized equipment (e.g., some facilities at Venture Centre, Pune).
    • Hardware Incubators: Requiring prototyping facilities, 3D printers, electronics labs.

In essence, incubation is required wherever there are aspiring entrepreneurs with promising ideas but a critical lack of the resources, mentorship, network, or infrastructure needed to transform those ideas into viable, scalable businesses. It serves as the fertile ground for innovation to take root and flourish.

How is Required Incubation?

Let’s clarify what “How is incubation required?” means. It’s not about a legal obligation, but rather the mechanisms and critical needs that make seeking incubation a necessary strategic choice for early-stage businesses. It outlines the specific ways an incubator fulfills a vital requirement for startup survival and growth.

Here’s how incubation is required:

1. By Providing Critical Resources and Infrastructure:

  • Mechanism: Incubators offer physical space (co-working, private offices), utilities, internet, meeting rooms, and sometimes specialized labs (for biotech, hardware, etc.) at significantly reduced costs or for free. They might also provide shared administrative support.
  • How it becomes “required”:
    • Capital Preservation: For bootstrapped or pre-seed startups, the initial capital outlay for office rent, utilities, and basic infrastructure is a major hurdle. Incubation is required to conserve scarce funds and extend runway.
    • Access to Specialized Facilities: Deep-tech or hardware startups often cannot afford or set up their own expensive labs, prototyping equipment, or specialized testing facilities. Incubation becomes essential by providing access to these.
    • Reduced Operational Hassle: Entrepreneurs can focus on product development and market validation rather than managing office logistics, which is crucial in the early, resource-constrained days.

2. By Bridging Knowledge and Experience Gaps (Mentorship & Education):

  • Mechanism: Incubators connect startups with experienced mentors (seasoned entrepreneurs, industry experts, investors), provide structured workshops, training sessions, and access to legal/financial advisors.
  • How it becomes “required”:
    • First-Time Entrepreneur Support: Many founders, particularly those from technical or academic backgrounds, lack practical business experience in areas like sales, marketing, fundraising, legal compliance, or team building. Incubation is required to fill these critical knowledge gaps through expert guidance.
    • Strategic Direction: Startups often need help validating their business model, refining their value proposition, or navigating market entry. Mentors provide crucial strategic direction and feedback, preventing costly mistakes.
    • Skill Development: Workshops provide hands-on training in essential startup skills that founders might not possess.

3. By Facilitating Access to Networks and Funding:

  • Mechanism: Incubators actively introduce startups to angel investors, venture capitalists, corporate partners, potential customers, and a community of peer entrepreneurs. They also assist with pitch preparation.
  • How it becomes “required”:
    • Capital Access: One of the biggest challenges for early-stage startups is securing funding. Incubators are required as a trusted intermediary that can vet and introduce startups to relevant investors, significantly increasing funding chances.
    • Market Validation and Partnerships: Connecting with early customers or industry partners through the incubator’s network is vital for market validation and potential pilot projects.
    • Peer Support and Collaboration: The community within an incubator fosters peer learning, idea exchange, and emotional support, which is critical for the often-isolating journey of entrepreneurship.

4. By Providing Structured Validation and Development Pathways:

  • Mechanism: Incubator programs often have structured curricula, milestone tracking, and regular review sessions.
  • How it becomes “required”:
    • Disciplined Development: For idea-stage or very early-stage startups, the structured environment helps them move systematically from concept to MVP to market entry, rather than operating haphazardly.
    • Accountability: Regular reviews with mentors and program managers provide accountability, ensuring startups stay on track and meet their development goals.
    • Risk Reduction: By forcing early validation and iteration, incubators help startups “fail fast” on non-viable ideas or pivot before significant resources are committed.

The “How” in Practical Terms:

When a startup “requires” incubation, it means they actively:

  1. Seek out and apply to reputable incubation programs.
  2. Commit to the program’s structure, attending workshops and engaging with mentors.
  3. Leverage the provided resources (workspace, legal advice, network introductions).
  4. Are willing to receive critical feedback and adapt their approach based on expert guidance.

In essence, incubation is “required” by filling fundamental gaps in resources, knowledge, and connections that, left unaddressed, would significantly hinder a startup’s ability to launch, validate, secure funding, and ultimately succeed. It’s a strategic necessity rather than a mandatory compliance step.

Case study on Incubation?

Courtesy: Hustle Inside

You’re looking for a concrete example of how incubation works in practice. Let’s explore a prominent case study from India’s vibrant startup ecosystem:

Case Study: Society for Innovation and Entrepreneurship (SINE), IIT Bombay

Incubator Profile:

  • Name: Society for Innovation and Entrepreneurship (SINE), IIT Bombay
  • Location: Indian Institute of Technology Bombay (IIT Bombay), Mumbai, Maharashtra, India.
  • Type: University-affiliated Technology Business Incubator (TBI).
  • Focus: Primarily deep-tech, science-based, and technology-driven startups, often spun out of IIT Bombay’s research or founded by its students, faculty, or alumni.
  • Established: Began as a pilot project in 1999, formalized as SINE in 2004.

The “Why” SINE is Required/Essential:

IIT Bombay is a hub of world-class scientific and engineering talent and research. However, for years, much of this innovation remained in labs or academic papers. SINE was established to address critical gaps in converting this intellectual property and talent into commercial ventures:

  1. Bridging the Research-to-Market Gap: Scientists and engineers excel in R&D but often lack business acumen, market understanding, or entrepreneurial experience.
  2. Access to Specialized Infrastructure: Deep-tech startups require expensive lab equipment, testing facilities, and computing power that individual startups cannot afford.
  3. Early-Stage Funding Challenges: Deep-tech ventures typically have longer gestation periods and higher upfront R&D costs, making it harder to attract conventional early-stage venture capital.
  4. Mentorship & Network: First-time founders need guidance on everything from legal incorporation and IP protection to fundraising strategies and team building.
  5. Credibility & Ecosystem Linkages: An IIT-backed incubator provides immediate credibility and connects startups to a powerful network of alumni, industry leaders, and investors.

How SINE Provides Incubation (Key Offerings and Impact):

SINE’s incubation model provides a comprehensive support system:

  1. Physical Infrastructure & Labs:
    • Offer: Provides subsidized office space within the IIT Bombay campus, access to university labs, equipment, and IT infrastructure.
    • Impact: Reduces operational costs significantly for startups, allows them to leverage cutting-edge research facilities directly, and fosters a collaborative environment.
  2. Mentorship and Expert Guidance:
    • Offer: A strong network of mentors including IIT Bombay faculty, successful alumni entrepreneurs, industry veterans, and domain experts. Provides structured mentorship sessions and business planning support.
    • Impact: Guides startups through product development, market validation, business model refinement, and strategic decision-making, helping them avoid common pitfalls and accelerate growth.
  3. Funding Facilitation:
    • Offer: Helps startups prepare compelling pitches, connects them with angel investors, VCs, and government grant programs (like those from DST, MeitY, BIRAC). SINE itself has launched a Rs. 100 crore venture fund to fuel deep-tech startups.
    • Impact: Addresses the critical challenge of early-stage funding, especially for deep-tech ventures with longer development cycles, enabling them to secure the capital needed for R&D and scaling.
  4. IP Protection and Legal Support:
    • Offer: Guidance on intellectual property (IP) protection, patent filing, legal incorporation, and contract drafting through retainer professional services (CAs, lawyers).
    • Impact: Safeguards the core innovation of the startups, ensuring their competitive advantage and making them more attractive to investors. SINE has facilitated the generation of over 300 intellectual properties.
  5. Talent Access and Recruitment:
    • Offer: Provides access to IIT Bombay’s vast student and alumni pool for potential hires, interns, and co-founders.
    • Impact: Helps startups build strong teams, leveraging the highly skilled talent available within the IIT ecosystem.
  6. Credibility and Brand Building:
    • Offer: Association with the IIT Bombay brand lends significant credibility to nascent startups. SINE helps in brand building and market exposure.
    • Impact: Opens doors to partnerships, customer acquisition, and investor conversations that would be difficult for an unincubated startup to achieve.

Notable Success Stories (Incubated by SINE):

SINE has a remarkable track record of nurturing high-impact startups. Some prominent examples include:

  • Gupshup: A global leader in conversational messaging, became the first unicorn (valued over $1 billion) to emerge from an academic incubation ecosystem in India.
  • ideaForge: India’s leading drone manufacturing company, which successfully went public, showcasing SINE’s impact on high-tech manufacturing and defense.
  • ImmunoACT: Pioneered India’s first indigenous CAR T-cell therapy for cancer, a groundbreaking medical innovation with significant societal impact.
  • TranscribeMe: A successful voice-to-text transcription service.

Outcomes and Overall Impact:

As of recent reports (early 2025), SINE has:

  • Supported over 245 startups that have collectively raised $942 million in funding.
  • Achieved a combined valuation of $3.6 billion for its portfolio companies.
  • Generated over 300 intellectual properties.
  • Played a pivotal role in fostering an entrepreneurial culture at IIT Bombay, with its entrepreneurs serving as role models.

Conclusion:

The SINE IIT Bombay case study exemplifies how a well-structured incubation program, particularly one affiliated with a premier academic institution, is absolutely “required” to convert promising ideas and cutting-edge research into successful, scalable businesses. It provides the crucial blend of infrastructure, mentorship, funding access, and credibility that early-stage deep-tech startups need to overcome significant hurdles and contribute meaningfully to the economy and society. Sources

White paper on Incubation?

White Paper: Business Incubation – Nurturing the Seeds of Innovation for Economic Growth

Abstract: In a global economy increasingly driven by innovation and entrepreneurial dynamism, business incubation has emerged as a cornerstone for fostering new ventures. This white paper defines business incubation as a systematic process of nurturing early-stage businesses (startups) by providing a comprehensive suite of support services, resources, and a conducive environment. It delves into the multifaceted “requirement” for incubation, highlighting how it addresses critical gaps in funding, mentorship, infrastructure, and market access that often hinder startup survival. We explore the diverse models of incubation, examine its profound benefits for both startups and the broader ecosystem, discuss common implementation challenges, and identify future trends shaping its evolution as an indispensable tool for economic development and diversification.

1. Introduction: The Imperative for New Venture Creation

The global economic landscape is undergoing profound transformations, marked by rapid technological advancements, evolving consumer behaviors, and an intensified competitive environment. In this context, the creation of new, innovative businesses – startups – is recognized as a vital engine for job creation, economic diversification, and technological progress. However, the journey of a startup is inherently fraught with high risks, limited resources, and significant knowledge gaps.

Business incubation programs have risen as a critical intervention to mitigate these risks. By offering a structured and supportive ecosystem, incubators play a pivotal role in transforming nascent ideas into viable, sustainable enterprises. This white paper will illuminate why incubation is not merely a supportive option, but often a fundamental “requirement” for the success of early-stage ventures.

2. Understanding Business Incubation: A Holistic Approach

Business incubation is a strategic process designed to accelerate the growth and success of new and early-stage companies. It operates on the premise that providing comprehensive support during a startup’s formative years significantly increases its chances of survival and scalability.

2.1. Definition: A business incubator is an organization that provides a range of support services, resources, and an enabling environment to assist startups in developing their businesses, typically during their most vulnerable initial phases. The core objective is to “nurture” these ventures until they are self-sufficient and capable of independent operation.

2.2. Core Pillars of Incubation: While offerings vary, effective incubation programs typically provide:

  • Physical or Virtual Workspace: Affordable or subsidized office space, co-working facilities, meeting rooms, and sometimes specialized labs or equipment (e.g., wet labs, prototyping workshops). Virtual incubation offers support without a dedicated physical presence.
  • Mentorship and Expert Guidance: Access to a network of seasoned entrepreneurs, industry veterans, domain experts, and specialized advisors (legal, financial, marketing). This includes structured mentorship programs and workshops.
  • Networking Opportunities: Facilitating connections with angel investors, venture capitalists, corporate partners, potential customers, suppliers, and a community of peer entrepreneurs.
  • Business Support Services: Direct or facilitated access to professional services like legal counsel (for incorporation, IP protection), accounting, taxation, and marketing/PR support.
  • Funding Assistance: Often providing small seed grants or linking startups directly to various funding sources (grants, angel networks, VCs).
  • Capacity Building: Training programs, workshops, and educational resources on various aspects of business management, entrepreneurship, and technical skills.

3. Why Incubation is “Required”: The Indispensable Role

The necessity of incubation stems from its ability to address critical challenges faced by early-stage ventures:

3.1. Mitigating High Failure Rates:

  • Problem: A significant percentage of startups fail within their first few years due to various reasons like lack of funding, market misalignment, weak business models, or inexperienced teams.
  • BPM’s Role: Incubators provide a protective ecosystem that reduces these risks. By offering resources, guidance, and validation mechanisms, they significantly increase a startup’s chances of survival and growth. This support is “required” to overcome the inherent fragility of new ventures.

3.2. Bridging Resource Gaps:

  • Problem: Startups, especially bootstrapped or pre-seed ventures, face severe constraints in terms of capital, infrastructure, and talent acquisition.
  • BPM’s Role: Incubators are “required” to bridge these gaps by providing subsidized office space, shared equipment, access to talent pools (e.g., from universities), and financial assistance or connections, allowing startups to conserve their limited funds and focus on core development.

3.3. Overcoming Knowledge and Experience Deficiencies:

  • Problem: Many first-time entrepreneurs possess innovative ideas or technical expertise but lack fundamental business acumen (e.g., sales, marketing, finance, legal, scaling).
  • BPM’s Role: Incubation is “required” to fill these crucial knowledge gaps through structured mentorship, educational workshops, and access to professional advisors. This accelerates the learning curve and prevents common, costly mistakes.

3.4. Facilitating Market Validation and Go-to-Market Strategy:

  • Problem: Startups often launch products without sufficient market validation, leading to wasted effort and resources on solutions no one needs.
  • BPM’s Role: Incubators are “required” to guide startups through rigorous market research, customer discovery, and MVP (Minimum Viable Product) development. They help refine the value proposition and develop effective go-to-market strategies, ensuring product-market fit.

3.5. Providing Access to Critical Networks and Funding:

  • Problem: Early-stage startups struggle to connect with relevant investors, industry players, or potential strategic partners.
  • BPM’s Role: Incubators are “required” as trusted intermediaries. They vet startups and connect them to their extensive networks of angel investors, venture capitalists, corporate clients, and other ecosystem players, significantly increasing their chances of securing follow-on funding and crucial partnerships.

3.6. Fostering a Culture of Innovation and Collaboration:

  • Problem: Innovation can be stifled in isolated environments, and startups often lack a supportive community.
  • BPM’s Role: By co-locating or connecting diverse startups, incubators create a vibrant, collaborative ecosystem. This environment is “required” for peer learning, idea exchange, and a culture of mutual support, which can significantly accelerate problem-solving and innovation.

4. Diverse Models of Incubation:

The “requirement” for incubation manifests in various specialized models:

  • University-Affiliated Incubators: Leverage academic research, faculty expertise, and student talent (e.g., SINE at IIT Bombay).
  • Government-Backed Incubators: Focus on regional economic development, job creation, and specific policy objectives (e.g., Atal Incubation Centres in India).
  • Corporate Incubators: Driven by large corporations to foster internal innovation, scout for new technologies, or integrate startups into their supply chains.
  • Non-Profit Incubators: Often focus on social enterprises, community development, or specific underserved sectors.
  • Virtual Incubators: Offer services remotely, reducing geographical barriers and often specializing in specific verticals.
  • Sector-Specific Incubators: Cater to the unique needs of industries like AgriTech, FinTech, BioTech, or CleanTech, providing specialized labs and domain expertise.

5. Challenges in Incubation Implementation:

Despite their vital role, incubators face challenges:

  • Sustainability: Many incubators, especially non-profit or government-backed ones, struggle with long-term financial sustainability.
  • Measuring Impact: Quantifying the direct ROI of incubation can be complex, making it difficult to secure consistent funding.
  • Quality of Mentorship: Ensuring a consistent supply of high-quality, engaged mentors.
  • Selection Bias: Rigorous selection processes are necessary but can inadvertently exclude unconventional yet promising ideas.
  • Post-Incubation Support: Ensuring startups continue to thrive after graduating from the program.
  • Scaling Services: Providing personalized attention as the number of incubatees grows.

6. The Future of Incubation: Adapting to New Realities

The landscape of incubation is continuously evolving to meet emerging demands:

  • Hybrid Models: Blending physical and virtual services for greater reach and flexibility.
  • Specialization: Increasing focus on niche industries or deep technologies to provide highly tailored support.
  • Global Networks: Incubators increasingly connecting startups to global markets, mentors, and investors.
  • Integration with Acceleration: A seamless continuum from early-stage nurturing (incubation) to rapid scaling (acceleration).
  • Leveraging Technology: Utilizing AI for mentor-startup matching, data analytics for program optimization, and online platforms for service delivery.
  • Focus on Impact: Beyond economic metrics, a growing emphasis on social and environmental impact for incubated ventures.

7. Conclusion: The Indispensable Ecosystem Enabler

Business incubation is no longer a peripheral support service; it is a fundamental requirement for the healthy functioning and growth of modern innovation ecosystems. By providing a nurturing environment, critical resources, expert guidance, and essential networks, incubators bridge the daunting gaps that often lead to startup failure. As economies worldwide increasingly rely on entrepreneurship and technological innovation for sustained progress, the strategic investment in and effective management of incubation programs will remain paramount. They are the essential cultivators ensuring that the seeds of innovation can germinate, flourish, and ultimately contribute to a more dynamic and prosperous future.

Industrial Application of Incubation?

“Industrial application of Incubation” refers to how business incubation specifically supports the growth of startups in traditional or heavy industries, often involving physical products, complex supply chains, specialized machinery, and significant capital expenditure. These differ from purely digital or service-based startups in their unique needs.

Here’s how incubation is applied in industrial contexts, with a focus on its relevance in India:

1. Manufacturing & Heavy Industry

  • Need for Specialized Infrastructure: Manufacturing startups often require access to expensive machinery, prototyping facilities, testing labs, and industrial-grade workspaces.
    • Incubation’s Application: Industrial incubators provide shared workshop space, access to CNC machines, 3D printers, specialized testing equipment, and even pilot production lines. This dramatically reduces the initial capital expenditure (CapEx) for startups. Examples in India include incubators focusing on automotive components, precision engineering, or consumer durables.
  • Supply Chain & Logistics Optimization: Industrial startups depend heavily on efficient supply chains.
    • Incubation’s Application: Mentors help refine supply chain strategies, connect startups with raw material suppliers, logistics partners, and distribution networks. Some incubators might even have tie-ups with larger manufacturing companies to pilot new solutions within their existing supply chains.
  • Quality Control & Compliance: Adhering to industrial standards (e.g., ISO, BIS in India), safety regulations, and quality control is paramount.
    • Incubation’s Application: Incubators provide guidance on quality management systems, certifications, and regulatory compliance, often connecting startups with experts in these fields.
  • Industry 4.0 & Digital Transformation: Integrating technologies like AI, IoT, robotics, and automation into manufacturing processes.
    • Incubation’s Application: Incubators focusing on Industry 4.0 provide technical expertise, sandbox environments for testing smart manufacturing solutions, and connections to relevant technology providers. They help traditional manufacturers embrace digital tools and automate processes.
  • Case Example (India): The Department for Promotion of Industry and Internal Trade (DPIIT) in India actively promotes manufacturing incubators to foster innovation in this sector. These centers offer plug-and-play options, shared facilities for product development and early-stage manufacturing, and act as an interface between startups and larger companies for pilot facilities and market access.

2. Automotive & Mobility

  • Need for Prototyping & Testing: Automotive startups (EVs, auto components, mobility solutions) require facilities for prototyping, vehicle testing, and component validation.
    • Incubation’s Application: Incubators provide access to automotive testing tracks (simulated), specialized labs for battery testing, motor design, and component validation. They also connect startups with established auto manufacturers for potential partnerships or supplier relationships.
  • Regulatory & Certification Hurdles: The automotive industry has stringent safety and emission regulations.
    • Incubation’s Application: Mentors guide startups through the complex certification processes (e.g., ARAI certifications in India) and help them understand regulatory frameworks.

3. AgriTech & Food Processing

  • Need for Pilot Plants & Field Testing: Startups developing new food products, agricultural machinery, or precision farming solutions need space for pilot production, controlled environment agriculture, or field trials.
    • Incubation’s Application: AgriTech incubators often have mini food processing units, greenhouses, experimental farm plots, and cold storage facilities. They connect startups with farmers for field trials and with food industry experts for product development and market access.
  • Supply Chain for Perishables: Managing the cold chain and distribution for agricultural produce is crucial.
    • Incubation’s Application: Guidance on supply chain optimization for perishable goods, food safety standards, and market linkages to aggregators or direct-to-consumer channels.
  • Case Example (India): a-IDEA (Association for Innovation Development of Entrepreneurship in Agriculture) at ICAR-NAARM, Hyderabad, is a prominent Agri-Business incubator that provides specialized support including lab access and field trial facilities.

4. Cleantech & Renewable Energy

  • Need for Testing & Demonstration Sites: Startups in solar, wind, waste-to-energy, or energy storage require facilities to test prototypes and demonstrate their solutions.
    • Incubation’s Application: Incubators provide testbeds for renewable energy technologies, access to grid simulators, or sites for waste processing pilots. They also connect startups with utilities or large industrial consumers for potential deployments.
  • Policy & Regulatory Landscape: The cleantech sector is heavily influenced by government policies and subsidies.
    • Incubation’s Application: Mentors provide expertise on relevant government policies, subsidies, and regulatory frameworks (e.g., related to renewable energy targets in India), helping startups navigate the complex policy environment.

5. Deep Tech (e.g., Advanced Materials, Nanotechnology, Biotech)

  • Need for High-End Research Labs: These startups often emerge directly from scientific research and require highly specialized (and expensive) laboratory equipment and expertise.
    • Incubation’s Application: University-affiliated incubators (like SINE at IIT Bombay or Venture Center in Pune) are crucial here. They offer access to advanced scientific instruments, clean rooms, wet labs, and specialized testing facilities, along with the mentorship of leading scientists and engineers.
  • Longer Development Cycles: Deep tech often has longer R&D and commercialization timelines.
    • Incubation’s Application: Incubators provide patient capital linkages and sustained support to endure these longer cycles, unlike traditional accelerators that focus on rapid scaling.

Overall Impact of Incubation in Industrial Applications:

  • Reduced Capital Outlay: By providing shared access to expensive machinery and labs, incubators lower the significant upfront investment required for industrial startups.
  • Faster Prototyping & Testing: Accelerates the product development cycle by providing immediate access to critical tools and expertise.
  • Market Validation in Real-World Contexts: Facilitates pilot projects and collaborations with larger industries, allowing startups to test their solutions in real operating environments.
  • Bridging the Academia-Industry Gap: Crucial for translating scientific research into commercial industrial applications.
  • Skilled Talent Pool: Many industrial incubators are linked to engineering colleges or research institutions, providing access to a specialized talent pool.
  • Policy & Regulatory Navigation: Guiding startups through complex industrial regulations and obtaining necessary certifications.

In essence, incubation in industrial applications is about creating an environment where high-tech, often hardware-intensive, and capital-intensive startups can de-risk their innovations, access specialized resources, and build foundational traction before scaling up to full-scale industrial operations.

References

[edit]

  1. ^ Jump up to:a b Ekarius, Carol (2007). Storey’s Illustrated Guide to Poultry Breeds. North Adams, MA: Storey Publishing. ISBN 978-1-58017-667-5.
  2. ^ Turner, J. Scott (1997). “On the Thermal Capacity of a Bird’s Egg Warmed by a Brood Patch” (PDF). Physiological Zoology. 70 (4): 470–80. doi:10.1086/515854. PMID 9237308. S2CID 26584982. Archived from the original (PDF) on 20 October 2022. Retrieved 29 July 2020 – via EBSCO.
  3. ^ De Marchi, G., Chiozzi, G., Fasola, M. 2008 Solar incubation cuts down parental care in a burrow nesting tropical shorebird, the crab plover Dromas ardeola. Journal of Avian Biology 39 (5):484–486
  4. ^ Athanasiadou, Dimitra; Jiang, Wenge; Goldbaum, Dina; Saleem, Aroba; Basu, Kaustuv; Pacella, Michael S.; Böhm, Corinna F.; Chromik, Richard R.; Hincke, Maxwell T.; Rodríguez-Navarro, Alejandro B.; Vali, Hojatollah; Wolf, Stephan E.; Gray, Jeffrey J.; Bui, Khanh Huy; McKee, Marc D. (2 March 2018). “Nanostructure, osteopontin, and mechanical properties of calcitic avian eggshell”. Science Advances. 4 (3): eaar3219. Bibcode:2018SciA….4.3219A. doi:10.1126/sciadv.aar3219. ISSN 2375-2548. PMC 5930395. PMID 29725615.
  5. ^ Diez-Méndez, David; Rodríguez, Samuel; Álvarez, Elena; Barba, Emilio (2020). “The role of partial incubation and egg repositioning within the clutch in hatching asynchrony and subsequent effects on breeding success”. Ibis. 162 (1): 63–74. doi:10.1111/ibi.12730. ISSN 1474-919X. S2CID 146021054.
  6. ^ Warham, J. (1990) The Petrels – Their Ecology and Breeding Systems London:Academic Press.
  7. ^ Pettingill, OS Jr. Ornithology in Laboratory and field (4 ed.). Burgess Publishing Company. pp. 357–360.
  8. ^ ‘Eggless’ chick laid by hen in Sri Lanka, BBC News Online, 19 April 2012, retrieved 28 April 2012
  9. ^ Divoky, G.J.; Harter, B.B. (2010). “Supernormal delay in hatching, embryo cold tolerance, and egg-fostering in the Black Guillemot Cepphus grylle“ (PDF). Marine Ornithology. 38: 7–10. Archived from the original (PDF) on 21 March 2012.
  10. ^ Wiebe, KL; Wiehn J; E Korpimaki (1998). “The onset of incubation in birds: can females control hatching patterns?” (PDF). Anim. Behav. 55 (4): 1043–1052. doi:10.1006/anbe.1997.0660. PMID 9632488. S2CID 26835907. Archived from the original (PDF) on 28 July 2011.
  11. ^ Erica Cromer (14 April 2004). “Monotreme Reproductive Biology and Behavior”. Iowa State University. Archived from the original on 13 March 2009. Retrieved 18 June 2009.
  12. ^ “Ockhams Razor”. The Puzzling Platypus. Archived from the original on 4 April 2005. Retrieved 2 December 2006.
  13. ^ Paul R. Manger; Leslie S. Hall; John D. Pettigrew (29 July 1998). “The development of the external features of the platypus (Ornithorhynchus anatinus)”. Philosophical Transactions: Biological Sciences. 353 (1372). The Royal Society: 1115–1125. doi:10.1098/rstb.1998.0270. PMC 1692310. PMID 9720109.
  14. ^ Stebbins, Robert C.; Cohen, Nathan W. (1995). A Natural History of Amphibians. Princeton University Press. p. 196. ISBN 978-0-691-03281-8.
  15. ^ Stebbins, Robert C.; Cohen, Nathan W. (1995). A Natural History of Amphibians. Princeton University Press. p. 200. ISBN 978-0-691-03281-8.
  16. ^ Stebbins, Robert C.; Cohen, Nathan W. (1995). A Natural History of Amphibians. Princeton University Press. pp. 202–204. ISBN 978-0-691-03281-8.
  17. ^ Ruppert, Edward E.; Fox, Richard S.; Barnes, Robert D. (2004). Invertebrate Zoology (7th ed.). Cengage Learning. pp. 62, 123, 297, 337, 364, 398, 811, 828, 887. ISBN 978-81-315-0104-7.
  18. Christensen, T. Bo (2005). Creative Cognition: Analogy and Incubation. Department of Psychology, University of Aarhus, Denmark
  19. ^ “Does incubation enhance problem-solving? A meta-analytic review”, Sio & Ormerod 2009
  20. ^ Dodds, A. Rebecca, Ward, B. Thomas, & Smith, M. Steven (2004). A Review of Experimental Research on Incubation in Problem Solving and Creativity. Texas A&M University
  21. ^ Barrett, Deirdre. The ‘Committee of Sleep’: A Study of Dream Incubation for Problem Solving. Dreaming: Journal of the Association for the Study of Dreams, 1993, 3, pp. 115-123.
  22. ^ Barrett, Deirdre. The Committee of Sleep: How Artists, Scientists, and Athletes Use their Dreams for Creative Problem Solving—and How You Can Too. NY: Crown Books/Random House, 2001
  23. ^ Domhoff, G. W. (2003). The Case Against the Problem-Solving Theory of Dreaming. Retrieved from the World Wide Web:http://dreamresearch.net/Library/domhoff_2004b.html
  24. AvianWe. “Atal Innovation Mission (AIM)”. Atal Innovation Mission (AIM). Retrieved 26 May 2025.
  25. ^ “Guidelines for setting up of Incubation Centres under Atal Innovation Mission – ‘Atal Incubation Centres'” (PDF). startupindia.gov.in. May 2026. Retrieved 26 May 2025.
  26. ^ Jump up to:a b AvianWe. “Atal Innovation Mission (AIM)”. Atal Innovation Mission (AIM). Retrieved 26 May 2025.
  27. ^ Jogeshwar, Ronak (24 February 2025). “Shaping Viksit Bharat: 50,000 Atal Tinkering Labs to drive innovation”. DD News. Retrieved 26 May 2025.
  28. ^ “Atal Tinkering Labs: Pune schools feel decision to expand labs will further foster creativity, innovation”. The Indian Express. 1 February 2025. Retrieved 26 May 2025.
  29. ^ “India’s Startup Revolution”. www.pib.gov.in. Archived from the original on 14 May 2025. Retrieved 26 May 2025.
  30. ^ Jump up to:a b AvianWe. “Atal Innovation Mission (AIM)”. Atal Innovation Mission (AIM). Retrieved 26 May 2025.
  31. ^ “Atal Incubation Centre at Dr Babasaheb Ambedkar Marathwada University receives over 1,600 applications for startups”. The Times of India. 3 April 2025. ISSN 0971-8257. Retrieved 26 May 2025.
  32. ^ Service, Express News (8 January 2025). “Atal Incubation Centre and T-Hub launch business incubation management programme”. The New Indian Express. Retrieved 26 May 2025.
  33.  Barret’s study on dream incubation (Dreaming, Vol. 3, No. 2, 1993) Accessed April 9, 2008
  34. ^ Incubating Dreams Solves Problems: A Description of Two Studies by Henry Reed, PhD
  35. ^ Barrett, Deirdre. The Committee of Sleep: How Artists, Scientists, and Athletes Use their Dreams for Creative Problem Solving—and How You Can Too. NY: Crown Books/Random House, 2001
  36. ^ How Can You Control Your Dreams?. Scientific American. 2010-07-29
  37. “Incubator Terminology Explained”. SureHatch. Retrieved 13 June 2018.
  38. ^ Society for the Diffusion of Useful Knowledge. “Egyptian Egg Oven”, The Penny Magazine, vol II, (England: August 10, 1833), p. 311-12.
  39. ^ The Egyptian Egg Ovens Considered More Wondrous Than the Pyramids, Atlas Obscura
  40. ^ Réaumur. Règles pour construire des thermomètres dont les degrés sont comparables et qui donnent une idée d’un chaud ou d’un froid qui puissent être rapportés à des mesures connues. Mémoire de l’Académie des Sciences de Paris, 1730
  41. ^ Rude, Emelyn (2016). Tastes Like Chicken: A History of America’s Favorite Bird. Wiley. ISBN 978-1-68177-163-2. Retrieved 25 August 2016.
  42. ^ “The History Of Incubation”. Pleysier. Archived from the original on 20 December 2013. Retrieved 7 September 2013.
  43. ^ “Ira M. Petersime dies; egg incubator maker”. Journal Herald. Dayton, Ohio. 25 January 1958.
  44. ^ “Another gem is added to Ohio’s crown”. Dayton Daily News. 12 December 1926.
  45. ^ “Inventor dies at 85”. Los Angeles Times. 26 January 1958.
  46. ^ “What is an Egg Incubator”. WiseGEEK. Retrieved 7 September 2013.
  47. ^ “Poultry: Reproduction & Incubation”. MSU Cares. Retrieved 7 September 2013.
  48. ^ Jump up to:a b “SmartPro Incubation”. PasReform. Retrieved 12 September 2014.
  49. ^ Jump up to:a b LINCO Incubator Research & development
  50. ^ Pas Reform Academy (2014). Incubation Guide Broiler v5, p:25
  51.  “What is business incubator?”. Archived from the original on 2016-04-22. Retrieved 2015-02-15.
  52. ^ Rubin, Tzameret H.; Aas, Tor Helge; Stead, Andrew (2015-07-01). “Knowledge flow in Technological Business Incubators: Evidence from Australia and Israel”. Technovation. 41–42: 11–24. doi:10.1016/j.technovation.2015.03.002.
  53. ^ Guadix, José (2016). “Success variables in science and technology parks”. Journal of Business Research. 69 (11): 4870–4875. doi:10.1016/j.jbusres.2016.04.045.
  54. ^ “Small Business Act”. Small Business Act. Retrieved 2019-12-07.
  55. ^ White, Doug and Polly (13 July 2017). “No One Can Match Silicon Valley, But Other Cities Benefit From Fostering Startups”. entrepreneur.com. Retrieved 20 March 2018.
  56. ^ Aerts, Kris; Matthyssens, Paul; Vandenbempt, Koen (2007-05-01). “Critical role and screening practices of European business incubators”. Technovation. 27 (5): 254–267. doi:10.1016/j.technovation.2006.12.002. ISSN 0166-4972.
  57. ^ “What are the best start-up accelerators in Germany? – TallyFox”. www.tallyfox.com. Retrieved 2021-05-21.
  58. ^ “Top Startup Accelerators, Incubators and VCs in Germany”. incubatorlist.com. Retrieved 2021-05-21.
  59. ^ “The top 40 startup accelerators and incubators in North America in 2021”. Salesflare Blog. 2020-10-06. Archived from the original on 2019-05-22. Retrieved 2021-05-21.
  60. ^ “Technology for Innovative Entrepreneurs & Businesses | TechLink”. techlinkcenter.org. Retrieved 2021-05-21.
  61. ^ “Incubator Austria Companies”. StartUs. Retrieved 2021-05-21.
  62. ^ Jump up to:a b c d e f g h Peters, Justin (June 28, 2017). “How a 1950s Egg Farm Hatched the Modern Startup Incubator”. Wired.
  63. ^ Centre for Strategy and Evaluation Services, “Benchmarking of Business Incubators.” Brussels: European Commission Enterprise Directorate General, 2002.
  64. ^ Jump up to:a b c d e f g h i j k Linda Knopp (2007). “2006 State of the Business Incubation Industry”. Athens, Ohio: National Business Incubation Association. Archived from the original on 2013-09-08. Retrieved 2015-05-26.
  65. ^ Edwards, Benj (February 17, 2017). “The Untold Story of Atari Founder Nolan Bushnell’s Visionary 1980s Tech Incubator”. Fast Company. Retrieved December 22, 2020.
  66. ^ “Small Business Administration”. Small Business Administration. Retrieved 2019-12-07.
  67. ^ Bone, Jonathan; Gonzalez-Uribe, Juanita; Haley, Christopher; Lahr, Henry (17 October 2019). “The impact of business accelerators and incubators in the UK”. {{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)
  68. ^ “Business Incubators: Meaning, Definition, Services, Development and Types”. Essays, Research Papers and Articles on Business Management. 2018-09-04. Retrieved 2019-12-07.
  69. ^ Bryan, Kevin A.; Tilcsik, András; Zhu, Brooklynn (2017). “Which Entrepreneurs are Coachable and Why?”. American Economic Review. 107 (5): 312–316. doi:10.1257/aer.p20171010. ISSN 0002-8282.
  70. ^ Meredith Erlewine, “Comparing Stats on Firm Survival.” In Measuring Your Business Incubator’s Economic Impact: A Toolkit. Athens, Ohio: National Business Incubation Association, 2007.
  71. ^ “About Us”.
  72. ^ Sekora, Michael (28 Jan 2010). Mastering the Art of Competition. New York, New York: Jossey Bass. ISBN 978-0-470-50071-2.
  73. ^ “EBN – European Business and Innovation Centre Network”.
  74. ^ Asish Das (26 April 2016). “How To Win Government Contracts For Your Startup”. The Startup Journal. Retrieved 30 April 2016.
  75. ^ Jump up to:a b Mascarenhas, Natasha (2020-10-15). “Startup founders set up hacker homes to recreate Silicon Valley synergy”. TechCrunch. Retrieved 2023-06-15.
  76. ^ “TechHousing – Urbanests”. Retrieved 2023-06-07.
  77. ^ “Inside SF’s Most Competitive ‘Hacker House'”. The San Francisco Standard. 2023-01-23. Retrieved 2023-06-15.
  78. ^ “Dreamers and dropouts: Stories from Stanford, cradle of unicorns”. The Economic Times. 2019-03-11. ISSN 0013-0389. Retrieved 2023-06-07.
  79. ^ Jump up to:a b Mascarenhas, Natasha (2020-10-15). “Startup founders set up hacker homes to recreate Silicon Valley synergy”. TechCrunch. Retrieved 2023-06-07.
  80. ^ Fink, Erica (2012-08-28). “Inside the ‘Social Network’ house”. CNNMoney. Retrieved 2023-06-07.
  81. ^ Fincher, David (2010-10-01), The Social Network (Biography, Drama), Jesse Eisenberg, Andrew Garfield, Justin Timberlake, Columbia Pictures, Relativity Media, Scott Rudin Productions, retrieved 2023-06-07
  82.  “balut”. Merriam-Webster Online Dictionary. Retrieved April 30, 2018.
  83. ^ Romjali, E.N.; Lambio, A.L.; Luis, E.S.; Roxas, N.P.; Barion, A.A. (2014). “Fertility and hatchability of eggs on mallard ducks (Anas platyrhynchos L.) of different plumage pattern under different feeding regimes”. JITV. 19 (3): 674–678.
  84. ^ Jump up to:a b Alejandria, Maria Carinnes P.; De Vergara, Tisha Isabelle M.; Colmenar, Karla Patricia M. (November 25, 2019). “The authentic balut: history, culture, and economy of a Philippine, Vietnam food icon”. Journal of Ethnic Foods. 6 (1): 16. doi:10.1186/s42779-019-0020-8. ISSN 2352-6181.
  85. ^ Magat, Margaret (2007). “‘Balut,’ the Fertilised Duck Eggs of the Philippines”. In Hosking, Richard (ed.). Eggs in Cookery: Proceedings of the Oxford Symposium of Food and Cookery 2006. Prospect Books. ISBN 978-1-903018-54-5.
  86. ^ Zaide, Gregorio (1964). History of the Filipino People. Manila: Modern Book Co.
  87. ^ Jump up to:a b c d Magat, Margaret (Spring 2002). “Balut: “Fertilized Duck Eggs and Their Role in Filipino Culture””. Western Folklore. 61 (1): 63–96. doi:10.2307/1500289. JSTOR 1500289.
  88. ^ Serena, Katie (November 21, 2021). “Introducing Balut Eggs – The World’s Weirdest Duck Dish”. All That’s Interesting. Retrieved October 19, 2023.
  89. ^ Jump up to:a b c R. Ehrlich, Paul. “Incubation: Heating Egg.” Incubation: Heating Egg. Web. February 29, 2016.
  90. ^ Matejowsky, T. (2013). “The Incredible, Edible Balut: Ethnographic Perspectives on the Philippines’ Favorite Liminal Food”. Food, Culture & Society. 16 (3): 387–404. doi:10.2752/175174413X13673466711723. S2CID 142396427.
  91. ^ Jump up to:a b Liedel, Emily (April 14, 2014). “Balut: The fertilized duck egg street snack”. Modern Farmer. Retrieved December 12, 2023.
  92. ^ Jump up to:a b “Course:FNH200/Lesson 02 – UBC Wiki”. wiki.ubc.ca. Retrieved March 21, 2016.
  93. ^ “Cooking and Chemical Changes.” BBC News. BBC, n.d. Web. February 29, 2016.
  94. ^ Jump up to:a b Kaewmanee, Thammarat; Benjakul, Soottawat; Visessanguan, Wonnop (2009). “Changes in chemical composition, physical properties and microstructure of duck egg as influenced by salting”. Food Chemistry. 112 (3): 560–569. doi:10.1016/j.foodchem.2008.06.011.
  95. ^ “Discover the Incredible Health Benefits of Balut: A Nutrient-Packed Delicacy”.
  96. ^ Lambio, A. L. (2010). Poultry Production in the Tropics. Quezon, Diliman, Philippines: The University of Philippines Press.
  97. ^ “Những điều cần lưu ý khi ăn trứng vịt lộn”.
  98. ^ “Grilled Balut of Vietnam: A Delicious and Nutritious Delicacy”. AnCu Life. April 2023. Retrieved April 1, 2023.
  99. ^ Jump up to:a b “In Some Countries People Eat Balut(egg) fertilized duck embryo”. 2012. Retrieved August 16, 2016.
  100. ^ “Best balut in Vancouver. (n.d.)”. Retrieved August 16, 2016.
  101. ^ Jump up to:a b Liedel, Emily (April 14, 2014). “Balut: The Fertilized Duck Egg Street Snack – Modern Farmer”. Retrieved August 16, 2016.
  102. ^ “What Is a Balut Egg?”. The San Francisco Chronicle. Archived from the original on December 30, 2016. Retrieved August 28, 2013.
  103. ^ Jump up to:a b “Enhancing the value of eggs: How to make balut and century eggs”. www.fftc.agnet.org. Retrieved August 15, 2016.
  104. ^ Jump up to:a b “Balut” (PDF). CPHAZ. March 3, 2016. Archived from the original (PDF) on April 4, 2016. Retrieved August 15, 2016.
  105. ^ Kosher and Non-Kosher Eggs Jewish Press. Retrieved December 4, 2018.
  106. ^ Jump up to:a b “Is eating egg haram / makruh – Multaqa Ahl al-Hadeeth”. August 28, 2011. Archived from the original on October 23, 2017. Retrieved August 16, 2016.
  107. ^ Tang, Q.; Li-Chan, E. C. Y.; Byrne, S. K.; Cheng, K. M. (February 1, 2019). Effect of storage temperature on sensory and microbiological quality of duck balut eggs. XXIII World Poultry Congress. Brisbane, Australia. p. 4.
  108. ^ “Food Code – FDA Food Code 2009: Annex 3 – Public Health Reasons / Administrative Guidelines – Chapter 1, Purpose and Definitions”. Center for Food Safety and Applied Nutrition. Archived from the original on March 31, 2013. Retrieved March 20, 2016.
  109. ^ Jump up to:a b Kilham, Chris (September 15, 2011). “Eating Balut: Going Too Far?”. Fox News. Retrieved August 15, 2016.
  110. ^ Leary, S.; et al. (2020). “AVMA Guidelines for the Euthanasia of Animals: 2020 Edition” (PDF). American Veterinary Medical Association. Retrieved July 15, 2024.
  111. ^ “Consolidated version of ASPA 1986”. Home Office (UK). 2014. Retrieved March 24, 2016.
  112. ^ “Is the practice of boiling pre-hatched duck embryos in their shell humane?”. RSPCA Australia knowledgebase. Retrieved October 10, 2016.
  113. ^ Matejowsky, T. (2013). The Incredible, Edible Balut. Food, Culture & Society, 16(3), 387–404.
  114. ^ San Jose, C.E. (April 13, 2015). “Animal rights activist: Stop serving ‘balut’ in New York”. Kicker Daily News. Retrieved March 20, 2016.
  115. ^ Calderon, J. (2014). “Balut: The Filipino delicacy that makes the world squirm”. CNN. Retrieved March 24, 2016.
  116. ^ Jump up to:a b Information Sheet (2011). “Balut” (PDF). University of Guelph. Archived from the original (PDF) on April 4, 2016. Retrieved March 24, 2016.
  117. ^ ‘Survivor: Caramoan’: It’s Corinne vs. Phillip when the tribes merge
  118. ^ “Balut gets spotlight in New York”. August 5, 2013.
  119. ^ “Philippines in world record attempt for largest serving of balut”. CNN Philippines. April 14, 2015. Archived from the original on April 30, 2018. Retrieved April 26, 2018.
  120. ^ “Pateros eyes world record attempt for balut”. ABS-CBN News. April 11, 2015. Retrieved April 27, 2018.

Table of Contents

×

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Translate »
Exit mobile version